Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Mandy Bauman's avatar

The statistic that Sarah shared that 86% of people who live in or near a large city does not say to me what it does to Sarah. As someone who has lived IN two large cites (NYC and Nashville), I would say that the people who live in the suburbs around large cities do not have the same perspective of the cities as the people who live IN them. I’ve had countless conversations with people who live near my city that show that they often think the city is more unsafe than it actually is. Many people who live near the city don’t actually go to the city often - or they only go for an event where they are in and out quickly, so their perspective isn’t as valuable to me as people who live there.

Expand full comment
Brooke Lawrence's avatar

About police officers! I’ve had my perspectives towards police officers challenged by some experiences I’ve had around police intervention in Atlanta. This is a journey from understanding police as deeply intertwined with white supremacy to feeling compelled to acknowledge and celebrate and protect the humanity and dignity of police officers.

I am a grad student at Emory, and in 2024, we had the protests for Palestine on our campus. Within twenty minutes, the president of our university called the Atlanta police and State Troopers to the campus. They preceded to tear gas everyone present with only a minute of warning to clear the Quad (our big green area). Over twenty students were arrested, and some were literally just Black students trying to get to their classes, who had nothing to do with the protests.

This was.. really painful and a big thing for my campus. I’m at the seminary, and I’ve seen video of police officers with machine guns walking through our building. The people of color I know who peacefully protested in our building genuinely feared for their lives. They thought they were about to die. This experience — especially the arrest of Black students who were just walking to class — brought me to realize the truth of the statement that the police were created to protect white supremacy. That’s in their design. I do think that’s true. The images of State Troopers terrorizing peaceful Black protesters and uninvolved students at my school helped sear that connection into my mind.

And honestly, it changed my relationship with police.. not as much as if I weren’t a white-passing student or if I were present on the Quad at the time of the tear gas, but it did really impact me. When driving from my aunt’s house in Atlanta, I would pass a police officer waving us through a broken traffic light and feel fear. When I left a play with my aunt and we held hands to weave through the crowd in the presence of police officers protecting that crowd, I was reminded of similar actions I’d taken with in the presence of law enforcement that was not for us, and thought about the precarious nature of when I’m protected and when I’m not.

Human dignity is my strongest value. I deeply believe that every person deserves to live, every person belongs, every person has a right to flourishing and humanization and that we must imagine everyone complexly. I understood, even at the time, that many police officers are very decent people who want to do their best to protect their communities. At the same time, I believed the police needed reform and acknowledgement and repentance of their racist roots and the ways that still impacts their practices, a position I still hold. But for over a year now, I’ve felt wary of police officers, with a sense of fear embedded from my experiences with those protests.

And then, a few weeks ago, there was the shooting that was sort of on Emory’s campus and directed at the CDC. A young police officer lost his life in that shooting. People I know and love were in the CDC buildings that shooter attacked. My friends and classmates were on campus and in apartments very close to the attack. I feel that this police officer, David Rose, died to protect these people I love, my community.

And since that happened… I’ve felt so much sadness and deep respect for this man. And I’ve told myself, I will honor police officers. I will honor their call and their sacrifice. I believe the police must be critiqued and reformed and perhaps rethought entirely. And there are really good and devoted people who work in police departments, and I want to affirm and celebrate them and support their humanity.

Expand full comment
101 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?