Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Sara  Duran's avatar

I think for me personally my life feels pretty fine and normal right now, it’s more about the anxiety I feel about the path we are on: If we will be able to afford healthcare, if people I love will be snatched up by ICE, if I will lose my job to AI, if my kids will be able to find jobs when they are ready to enter the workforce, etc.

Expand full comment
Kathryn Costanza's avatar

Re: Luigi Mangione and political violence...

Sarah, I so appreciate your point that we must cultivate humanity in ourselves. This is something I've been feeling in myself so strongly this year. May I suggest that one of Pantsuit Politics slow reads is the works of MLK, particularly Strength to Love? If we ever needed work on a love ethic - towards those who oppress, towards those who harm, towards repair - its now.

This year, following the assassination of Former Speaker Hortman and shooting if Sen. Hoffman in MN, I see a much clearer throughline between political violence, powerlessness, and health policy. The person who murdered Speaker Hortman did so in part because of her position on abortion and targeted other lawmakers for that reason as well.

Health care is so entangled with how people feel dignity and care towards their bodies and lives (and those of others). And in a system where people feel powerless in something so intimate and personal - so literally tied to life and death - it strips away their capacity for compassion.

As I said then, and I'll say again now, the lack of humanity health companies show people who need health care is part of this spiral that engendered a lack of humanity towards Brian Thompson when he was literally murdered. It's a dark spiral where dehumanization begets dehumanization.

I believe that connection and nonviolent action is the path to change, but I understand why people feel so powerless that it feels like violence is the only response. I worry that when we only see stagnation, that it contributes to our feeling of powerlessness and shrinks our perception - the aperture - of available options for change until all we see is violence.

I worry that the way the left talks about Medicaid cuts and states ending health coverage for immigrants narrows the aperture on the left, until it feels like the only solution is dehumanizing the other side by calling them killers which just moves us closer to violence.

It is true that the lack of health coverage means that some people will die. And it is also true that violence will not solve this, only policy reform. It may feel worse because the Trump administration is doing this, but at the end if the day, health policy is still just policy. This isn't even new policy - its the same old stuff rehashed again, that the ACA was enacted to combat 15 years ago. Its still subject to all the normal policy levers and creative policy solutions.

But when framed as life and death, what options feel open to people? What means will justify the perceived ends?

Expand full comment
50 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?