400 Applicants for a Barista Job: Our Community on the Real Job Market
Your Stories From the Job Market Front Lines
This week negotiation expert Kim Miller talked to me about navigating today’s job market.
The response from all of y’all was overwhelming. You didn’t just agree (or disagree, for that matter) with the advice. You told us what it actually feels like out there right now.
The playing field was never level
One of the most-liked comments in the thread came from Kelsey, who grew up in a blue collar family and eventually became a lawyer. She pushed back on the networking advice that feels so natural to some.
“In my experience, the culture in blue collar communities views interpersonal relationships as relationships. Either you enjoy another person's company or you don't and avoid them! You don't think about how someone can help you. (But you sure as hell offer help, whether labor or money, when you have a relationship with someone who is struggling but not asking for help.)”
Beth replied that Kelsey had given her words for her own experience. Dozens of you agreed. The thread that followed was a masterclass in how class shapes career — from not understanding internships (”I didn’t understand working for free”), to missing the unspoken social codes that some people absorb from birth.
If you’ve ever felt like everyone else got a manual you didn’t receive, you’re not imagining it. The manual exists. It just wasn’t distributed equally.
This week’s newsletter is sponsored by Babbel
Learn a new Language and get up to 60% off your subscription at Babbel.com/PANTSUITNEWSLETTER
The “safe” paths aren’t safe anymore
If the networking conversation revealed old inequities, the job search stories revealed new ones. And they weren’t just about entry-level workers.
One person shared that a family member with a “safe” degree cannot get an interview. Another wrote that their spouse’s position was eliminated and they have applied across completely different fields. Most applications, she said, feel like they disappear into a hole.
A member described her son graduating with a master’s in data science from a prestigious university — someone who, by any traditional measure, “did everything right” — who can’t get past an AI screening call.
Which brings us to the robots.
Multiple members flagged what might be the most disorienting development in an already disorienting market: AI is now the first gatekeeper for most applications, and it doesn’t reward qualifications. It rewards keywords. One member shared a study showing that AI screeners actually show a preference for resumes written with the same large language model the employer is using — but applicants have no way of knowing which one that is.
But here’s what Kim wants you to know
When Kim Miller — our guest — saw the thread filling up with these stories, she showed up in the comments.
“I just don’t think we need more fear right now,” she wrote. “I teach undergraduate students, and so many of them have already secured jobs. It is possible.”
Kim’s point throughout the episode — and in the thread — wasn’t that the market is fine. It’s that the skills which have always mattered most are the ones hardest to automate and hardest to screen out: genuine relationships, broad problem-solving ability, a track record of showing up and contributing. The students she sees succeeding aren’t necessarily the ones with the most prestigious degrees. They’re the ones who collected experiences, built real relationships with professors and mentors, and learned how to communicate their value to another human being.
That’s cold comfort if you’re currently staring at a rejection folder, or if you’re a kid who just got turned down for a summer job that used to go to anyone with a pulse. We hear you. The market is strange right now in ways that don’t show up in the unemployment rate..
We’re going to keep this conversation flowing, because - whatever the next job report might show - this issue isn’t going anywhere.